Why is this girl giving me mixed signals? (and what to do)

by Harsh Kushwah

girl giving me mixed signals

Among the many reasons for sending mixed signals, ‘attachment’ styles may be one reason. Some people wish to be connected but have difficulty expressing emotions.

Read the full article to understand better.

“I don’t know what she wants.”

“I don’t know what she expects.”

Why is this girl giving me mixed signals?”

Have you ever thought of such questions while dating a woman? 

Forget dating, even in a regular conversation with a woman. Have you ever felt that you couldn’t understand what she actually wanted? If yes, then continue reading. 

A lot of men need help understanding what a woman really means. Like the book ‘Men are from Mars, Women are from Venuscovers – there are a few confusing differences sometimes!

Perhaps, some people are not very good at “getting the point;” sometimes, the woman might not be too comfortable or experienced at expressing her point. And sometimes, it’s no one’s fault!

Yes, you read it right. It’s NO ONE’s fault. Sometimes it is simply a miscommunication, not some sinister intention by the parties involved.

Before discussing miscommunication, let me tell you something some people may prefer to avoid admitting – 

“People generally aren’t good at expressing what they mean.”

When someone is unaware of an appropriate way of expressing themselves, problems can ensue.

It can all result in false expectations, arguments, and even conflicts. It can stem from many reasons, including someone’s upbringing and social environment. 

And with Social Media and online conversations, words, actions, or signals that suggest “true feelings” or intentions can easily get lost in the “noise.” The result is often communication errors and “lost in translation” moments. The simple misuse of an emoji frequently misrepresents a person’s tone and other aspects of communication, leaving one person smiling and another scratching their head!

What actually is Mixed Signals?

Well, well, well – how many men spend significant parts of their lives trying to solve this question! 

They might go back through conversations in their mind, check forums, ask their friends, and even read books to understand what a woman meant by her words.

head scratcher confused girl giving me mixed signals,why is she giving me mixed signals,what to do when a girl gives you mixed signals,how to deal with mixed signals from a girl

As most of us aren’t good at expressing ourselves, we aren’t good at understanding the expressions of others. There, I said it – we might have to start with ourselves! Check out Men’s Guide To Communicate Better In A Relationship

This lack of ability to express can quickly become a lack of ability to comprehend others.

i dont understand what does that mean benjamin papac girl giving me mixed signals,why is she giving me mixed signals,what to do when a girl gives you mixed signals,how to deal with mixed signals from a girl

Communication is a skill to express, and lack of it can lead to wrong “signals” or at least “mixed signals”. And often, these signals get distorted. That means you aren’t receiving the message the sender intended to give in its “truest” form. This is called a “Mixed Signal”.

Mixed signals mean you need help understanding the various communication elements and intended messages.

And Mixed Signals can also mean you recognise ‘innocent’ words or actions as signals, but they aren’t.

im not trying to think about it too much marco wilson three girl giving me mixed signals,why is she giving me mixed signals,what to do when a girl gives you mixed signals,how to deal with mixed signals from a girl

Human communication and conversations often occur in two basic forms: Verbal and Non-verbal (Many people have ‘mixed signals’ about these, too!).

What if it is Misinterpretation altogether

Now, when you get mixed signals from a woman, remember this: A guy can easily misinterpret words.

Also Read- 13 Signs a Girl secretly likes you

And the same applies to non-verbal communication, which could include body language, visual, written communication etc. 

A man can easily misinterpret a woman’s body language or, indeed, any number of non-verbal forms of communication.

A woman might not want your attention, but due to distortion in communication, it can lead to the wrong conclusion. Have any of you been shocked when someone reacted the opposite as you expected? Getting caught in a web of mixed messages and signs is so easy.

Also, another thing. This might sound like a surprise (not!) –

“A woman might not even be giving you any signal, and you might misconstrue it, even a simple action or gesture, into a non-verbal signal.”

The last statement is often taken as a “mixed signal” – but isn’t a signal in the first place! If you remember this point alone, you might avoid many of these “mixed signals”.

Takeaway Tip– Before taking something as a mixed signal, ask yourself, is it actually a signal, or are you interpreting it as one? 

The Cause of Mixed Signals

As explained earlier, mixed signals are essentially miscommunication. To understand what causes mixed signals, we can explore what causes miscommunication.

Communication, in simpler terms, involves the sender, medium and receiver.

So, miscommunication can happen when there is an error in any of these three elements. You might send a mixed signal; the means of communication or medium might cause it, or as a receiver, you might wrongly interpret it, resulting in a mixed signal.

There have been various studies conducted over the years that have tried to understand common miscommunications between men and women.

This study explains what many of us already kind of know – 

Men are more likely to think a women’s friendliness means she is sexually interested in them. In contrast, women often misread men’s attempts to connect as partners as attempts to be friends instead! So, basically, the opposite!

Reasons to “Why this girl giving me mixed signals?”

Among the many reasons for sending mixed signals, ‘attachment’ styles may be one reason. Attachment styles are learned coping mechanisms and ways of attaching to people.

mixed signals reasons reddit

Some people wish to be connected but have difficulty expressing emotions and dealing with physical closeness. It can lead them to give out mixed signals. Their words and actions don’t match their intentions.

They create a “wall” that needs patience and emotional energy to break through.

what to do when she gives mixed signals

Takeaway Tip– Take mixed signals as a lack of healthy communication skills. Don’t rush to judge the meaning or blame yourself (or someone else!).

Types of Mixed Signals

Below are a few scenarios some of you may relate to – 

1. When she doesn’t reply to you when you expect

why is she giving me mixed signals

Suppose she delays answering messages or ignores your messages while being completely conversational some time ago. In that case, that might be a mixed signal. Not answering specific topics is also a mixed signal. A lot of people, women too, may have difficulty dealing with certain kinds of conversation, and they tend to avoid the topic, which can cause distress or anxiety.

2. When she doesn’t show up when you have planned for it

why is she giving me mixed signals

Suppose she agrees to a plan and chooses not to show up. In that case, that is also a mixed signal that she might not feel comfortable in the physical presence of the relationship. It is easier to have a conversation behind a wall of digital devices than to conduct a face-to-face conversation. (Not showing up could apply to meetings both online or offline).

3. When she talks in double meaning but doesn’t realise

why is she giving me mixed signals

Most of the time, she might not even feel her words have another meaning, which might be why she might not admit it. It can also happen if she wants to avoid being called out about her mixed signals. 

4. When she doesn’t show a connection with you in front of others but wants things hidden

Some women may be uncomfortable acknowledging their relationships in front of others depending on societal norms and behaviours. Let’s face it; women often face judgements from others when it comes to behaviour and relationships.

5. When she doesn’t tell you what she wants but expects you to read her mind.

This aspect is true in any relationship. Many people expect mind reading, which can easily lead to wrong expectations from each other. 

6. When she openly says to read between the lines, she essentially sends mixed signals voluntarily.

Some women may have difficulty admitting their real feelings and emotions and often talk in ‘code’ language. It might be due to inherent insecurity and fear that can make them employ such “signalling”.

7. When she says you don’t get me or not listening to what she is saying

It happens due to the “mind reading” expectations from guys. But sometimes, due to different expectations, value systems, listening habits and conversational styles, a man might need help understanding the intended message of a woman. Hence, this mixed signal.

Look closely. It means it has much to do with expectations – Yours and hers. Also, it shows a lack of trust and fear, which might influence them not to convey their real feelings.

What should I do? – How to deal with mixed signals from a girl

what to do when a girl gives you mixed signals
  1. Pay attention to Actions, not just Words

A practical way to deal with mixed signals is to compare a person’s words with their actions.

If a woman you know seems distant in words but shows care and affection in her actions, then focus more on her actions and efforts – This is a common mixed signal.

  1. Take time out to improve communication.

When you feel she is giving a mixed signal, take that as a sign that some vital communication is missing. How to deal with it?

Ask for a detailed conversation.

Try and make yourself available to what she has to say and make her comfortable to allow her to reveal her real intentions. Handle how you communicate to make yourself understood and help clear the mixed signal. 

  1. Patience 

If you slow down things, take some more time and observe closely, you can efficiently work through missed signals. You will start to see real intentions, if there are any. It also helps you ignore words or actions that aren’t even signals!

  1. Observing the behaviour 

Another way to deal with mixed signals is to look for tell-tale signs that lead to mixed signals about a particular topic. If you focus on the conversation or actions, you can find out what leads to a mixed signal.

  1. Compassion 

Being compassionate can help people move into a comfort zone and feel secure. It can help her communicate what she wants to say instead of sending those pesky mixed signals. Also, it will reduce your reactivity, which might scare them off.

  1. Draw your boundaries 

Of course, some women may deliberately send mixed signals and cause confusion.

It may be a dysfunctional communication style or adaptation, but all the same, it can cause significant distress.

If you sense someone is actively engaging in mixed signals, that’s not a behaviour you have to tolerate. Set your boundaries.

Don’t let someone cause you to react or draw you into their troubles. Stop the conversation if there are mixed signals. Being compassionate is admirable, but not to the extent that it affects your mental peace. 

  1. Work on yourself

If you see a lot of mixed signals, the other person may not be the problem.

Entertain the possibility that you might be reading too much into everything.

So, if you encounter too many mixed signals from a woman, ask yourself, is she sending you a signal, or is it just in your mind? Sometimes, a guy might become more prone to misinterpreting signals due to a lack of experience or good communication skills with women. In this case, you can learn to observe the conversation and understand the purpose of the discussion before rushing to a conclusion.

Communication remains to be at the foundation of human development.

It fosters new relationships and shapes society. However, miscommunication can do just the opposite. So, when dealing with mixed signals, remember that one of the best ways is to ignore the signal before blaming someone or even the mode of communication. If you can’t ignore it, then at least don’t prioritise.  

And last but not least, EVERY word, action or gesture is not necessarily a signal! Remember, this point alone can help you deal with the sometimes hazardous world of “mixed signals” and communication.

Hopefully, now you know what to do when a girl gives you mixed signals. Let me know in the comments what you think.



FAQs on Mixed Signals from a Girl

  1. What are Mixed Signals from a Crush? – Examples

    Is your crush sending you mixed signals? Here are a few examples of how to identify mixed signals that may come your way from someone who secretly likes you:
    — Your crush may fake incompetence
    — Pretend to be interested in your hobbies
    — They may remember every small detail you tell them
    — Start to tell you about their favourite things like movies, music etc
    — Get her friends to check you out
    — Exhibit territorial behaviour

    If you need more information on the above, or just to understand mixed signals from a girl, click Here for a more in-depth look at the Secret Signs Someone is Crushing on You

  2. What if a Girl Gives You Mixed Signals?

    Here’s what to do if a girl gives you mixed signals. You need to identify where the problem lies:

    — Is it you? Are you misinterpreting behaviour or words? (A smile might mean she is happy – and not a signal for you to approach her),
    — It might be that her gestures mean nothing related to you – they are just gestures.
     Or perhaps she is confused and not good at communicating (not everyone learns healthy ways to say what they mean).

    Many people are socially conditioned to behave in certain ways, and this can include not being direct or forward (women are especially conditioned to not be assertive or direct in some societies). 
    This can on occasion lead to what is referred to as “mixed signals” because the person cannot really say what they mean – it’s not acceptable.
    For example – she might not be able to ask you on a date, but instead, she will discuss a friend’s date or throw hints about a movie she wants to see.

Scroll to Top